Steve Young is often the first name that comes to mind when discussing BYU football legends. His journey from Provo to the NFL is a testament to his talent and determination. Young played at BYU from 1981 to 1983, where he showcased his dual-threat abilities as a quarterback who could both pass and run with exceptional skill. His versatility on the field was unmatched, setting a new standard for what a collegiate quarterback could achieve.
College Career Highlights
Young’s senior year in 1983 was nothing short of spectacular. He completed 71.3% of his passes for 3,902 yards and 33 touchdowns. His ability to make plays with his legs added another dimension to his game, rushing for 444 yards and eight touchdowns. Young’s performance earned him the Davey O’Brien Award, given to the nation’s top quarterback, and he finished second in the Heisman Trophy voting. His passing efficiency and ability to read defenses made him a formidable opponent, and his dual-threat capacity was a precursor to the modern quarterbacking style that has become prevalent in college football today.
Legacy at BYU
Steve Young’s legacy at BYU extends beyond his impressive statistics. He helped set the stage for future quarterbacks in the program and played a crucial role in establishing BYU as a powerhouse in college football. His leadership and charisma on the field inspired both teammates and fans alike, creating a culture of excellence and ambition. Young’s success at BYU paved the way for a Hall of Fame career in the NFL, where he continued to break records and win Super Bowls. His influence is still seen in the program’s emphasis on developing versatile and dynamic quarterbacks who can excel at the highest levels of the sport.
Ty Detmer: The Record Breaker
Ty Detmer is another iconic figure in BYU’s storied football history. Playing from 1988 to 1991, Detmer rewrote the NCAA record books with his incredible passing ability and football IQ. His tenure at BYU was marked by jaw-dropping performances and unforgettable moments. Detmer’s cerebral approach to the game and his exceptional ability to read defenses made him a formidable opponent and a beloved figure in BYU football lore.
College Career Highlights
Detmer’s breakout year came in 1990 when he won the Heisman Trophy, becoming the first BYU player to achieve this honor. That season, he threw for 5,188 yards and 41 touchdowns, breaking numerous NCAA records along the way. Detmer’s ability to dissect defenses and make precise throws made him a nightmare for opposing teams. His record-setting achievements put BYU in the national spotlight and demonstrated the potential of the program to produce top-tier talent capable of competing at the highest levels.
Legacy at BYU
Ty Detmer’s impact on BYU football is immeasurable. He holds several NCAA records, including career passing yards and touchdowns. Detmer’s achievements on the field helped solidify BYU’s reputation as a “Quarterback Factory,” a moniker that continues to attract talented quarterbacks to the program. His influence is still felt today, as young quarterbacks look up to his example of excellence and leadership. Detmer’s legacy is not only in the records he set but also in the inspiration he provides to future generations of players who aspire to reach the heights he achieved.
Jim McMahon: The Maverick
Jim McMahon, known for his maverick personality and fearless play, is a true legend of BYU football. Playing from 1977 to 1981, McMahon brought swagger and confidence to the quarterback position, thrilling fans with his audacious style and remarkable talent. His ability to perform with flair and take risks on the field made him a standout player who captivated audiences and left a lasting impression on the program.
College Career Highlights
McMahon’s senior year in 1981 was a masterclass in quarterbacking. He threw for 4,571 yards and 47 touchdowns, leading BYU to an 11-2 record and a victory in the Holiday Bowl. McMahon’s ability to perform in high-pressure situations was unmatched, and his leadership on the field was a driving force behind BYU’s success. His daring plays and willingness to push the envelope set a new standard for quarterback play at BYU, inspiring future players to embrace creativity and confidence in their approach.
Legacy at BYU
Jim McMahon’s legacy at BYU is one of innovation and success. He was a pioneer of the high-powered passing offense that became synonymous with BYU football. McMahon’s rebellious spirit and incredible performances left an indelible mark on the program, inspiring future generations of quarterbacks. His approach to the game, marked by both skill and swagger, has become an integral part of BYU’s football identity, influencing not only the style of play but also the culture of the team.
Max Hall: The Winningest Quarterback
Max Hall may not have the same national acclaim as some of his predecessors, but his contributions to BYU football cannot be overlooked. Playing from 2007 to 2009, Hall became the winningest quarterback in school history, leading the Cougars to numerous victories and bowl appearances. His consistency and ability to win under pressure solidified his place among the greats of BYU football.
College Career Highlights
Hall’s 2009 season was particularly memorable, as he led BYU to an 11-2 record and a victory over Oregon State in the Las Vegas Bowl. During his career, Hall threw for 11,365 yards and 94 touchdowns, solidifying his place among the greats of BYU football. His leadership on the field and ability to rally his team in crucial moments made him a standout player who was respected by both teammates and opponents.
Legacy at BYU
Max Hall’s legacy at BYU is characterized by his consistent success and leadership on the field. His ability to win games and perform under pressure made him a fan favorite and a respected figure in the program. Hall’s contributions helped maintain BYU’s status as a competitive force in college football. His tenure as quarterback continues to serve as a benchmark for success, inspiring future players to strive for excellence in both performance and leadership.
Honorable Mentions
While our Mount Rushmore includes only four players, several others have made significant contributions to BYU football and deserve recognition. These athletes have each brought something unique to the program, further enriching its storied history.
Marc Wilson
Marc Wilson was a standout quarterback from 1977 to 1979, paving the way for future BYU quarterbacks with his exceptional passing skills. His ability to execute the passing game with precision laid the groundwork for the quarterback-centric approach that has become a hallmark of BYU football. Wilson’s contributions set the stage for the prolific passing offenses that would follow, influencing the development of the program for years to come.
Austin Collie
Austin Collie, a wide receiver from 2004 to 2008, was known for his reliable hands and knack for making big plays in crucial moments. His ability to consistently perform at a high level made him a key player for the Cougars and a favorite target for quarterbacks. Collie’s impact on the field was matched by his work ethic and dedication, setting an example for future wide receivers and solidifying his place in BYU football history.
Luke Staley
Luke Staley, who played from 1999 to 2001, was a dominant running back whose 2001 season earned him the Doak Walker Award as the nation’s top running back. His explosive running style and ability to break tackles made him a formidable force on the field, contributing significantly to the team’s success during his tenure. Staley’s legacy is one of power and determination, inspiring future running backs to reach new heights in their performance.
Conclusion
BYU football has a rich history filled with remarkable players who have left a lasting impact on the program. Steve Young, Ty Detmer, Jim McMahon, and Max Hall represent the pinnacle of success and are deserving of their place on BYU Football’s Mount Rushmore. Their contributions, both on and off the field, have shaped the legacy of BYU football and continue to inspire future generations of athletes. As the program continues to evolve, these legends serve as a reminder of the standards of excellence and the potential that lies within every player who dons the blue and white.
